J Alex wrote:
> <sybrandb_at_yahoo.com> wrote
>
>>"J Alex" <nospam_at_nospam.net> wrote
>>
>>>My 2 cents - college degrees matter in IT, just like they do in every
>
> other
>
>>>professional field. The problem-hires I've seen have been when companies
>>>hire people without degrees, or with degrees in unrelated fields. As the
>>>field matures and companies start requiring comp. sci. degrees, the
>
> problem
>
>>>of unqualified people will disappear.
>>
>>
>>It is just nonsense you need a comp.sci degree to be successful in IT.
>
>
> I never said that.
>
>
>>Comp.sci has very little to do with practical IT.
>
>
> Depends on the program I guess, but I learned lots of practical IT,
> especially development methods and good practices. I'd say the classes were
> a 50-50 mix of programming classes and theory.
>
>
>>People with a
>>comp.sci degree aren't necessarily better developers or administrators
>>compare to people without such a degree.
>
>
> Sure they do. Some people without the degrees are very good, but invariably
> the developers/dbas that have been least effective have not had an
> IT-related degree. Why do you think IT is so different than say, chemistry
> or geology?
>
Right - thank you. I'm from the era comp.sci education had to be
invented. By your default, I would be less effective than you.
Funny how many companies ask for me by name, then.
Oh - I see; I'm one the the exceptions?!?
>
>>There is no problem of 'unqualified people'.
>
>
> Then why are people on this board advocating certification requirements? If
> everybody in IT is fully qualified to do their job, then certification is a
> waste of time. And if there is no problem with unqualified people, why did
> you say "I routinely notice all people working in IT younger than about 30
> usually don't know anything about development methods and logical thinking."
> Please be consistent in your posts.
>
Hmmm - I do see a lot from Daniel Morgan. And with his background (he's
in the teaching business) I see another point why he would defend
regulation and advertise more education (if that is the right way to put
it; I don't mean advertise in any commercial way).
--
Regards,
Frank van Bortel
Received on Thu Jan 08 2004 - 14:50:34 CST