Re: more on delete from join

From: Marshall <marshall.spight_at_gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2009 08:19:30 -0700 (PDT)
Message-ID: <acce30bf-51c4-4f60-aff7-6a8afc279431_at_13g2000prl.googlegroups.com>



On Sep 2, 5:31 am, "Walter Mitty" <wami..._at_verizon.net> wrote:
> "Marshall" <marshall.spi..._at_gmail.com> wrote in message
>
> news:eb8688da-8577-4088-9d0f-b4b46b1cb696_at_p10g2000prm.googlegroups.com...
> On Sep 1, 8:03 am, Kevin Kirkpatrick <kvnkrkpt..._at_gmail.com> wrote:
> <qoute>
> And if it still looks like guessing to you, you still haven't
> grasped the concept. Is solving systems of _linear_
> equations "guessing?" No; it is a process that is entirely
> deterministic and arithmetically sound. The identical
> qualities hold under the idea of solving systems of
> relational expressions.
> </quote>
>
> A minor quibble.  It is a process whose outcome is entirely deterministic.
> The process itself may rely on heuristics to determine the course of action
> needed to solve the system of equations.

Sure. But note that an optimizer needs to 1) find the fastest way
2) to determine the query results.

It is heuristic in 1, algorithmic in 2.

Marshall

> When I learned algebra in high school,  we learned various methods of
> solving systems of equations.  Only one of them, the determinant method, was
> guaranteed to work for every solvable system.  And the determinant method
> was a royal pain.  So,  if you could find one of the easier methods that
> worked,  such as removing common factors,  you could solve the system much
> more easily.
>
> You see, a solution strategy really is an imperative:  do this, then do
> that,  then do that, and you'll get the solution.  The validity of a
> strategy is a matter of strict logic.  The applicability of a given strategy
> to a given problem might or might not be a matter of strict logic.  It
> certainly wasn't taught that way, when I took algebra.
>
> All of this reminds me a little bit of query optimization in a DBMS.
> Composers of queries are encouraged to think of the query as specifying what
> is to be found, rather than how to find it.  The DBMS, on the other hand,
> generates an imperative strategy for carrying out the request.  The strategy
> generator portion of an optimizer certainly uses heuristics for generating
> strategies to be cost evaluated.  Hopefully, the strategy generator
> generates no incorrect strategies, just some costly ones.
Received on Wed Sep 02 2009 - 10:19:30 CDT

Original text of this message