Re: Lessons (was Re: Objects and Relations)
From: Bob Badour <bbadour_at_pei.sympatico.ca>
Date: Mon, 12 Feb 2007 18:27:01 GMT
Message-ID: <Vj2Ah.5578$R71.84637_at_ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca>
>
> Let's not let that happen. Teaching the wrong lesson will frustrate.
> Addressing the wrong audience will frustrate. Using an ineffective
> approach will frustrate. Can you think of any other potential causes of
> frustration?
>
> I have a conjecture--perhaps even an hypothesis: With intellectual
> honesty and sincerity, one can choose effectiveness.
>
> Let's start by taking an inventory. When answering the following, strive
> for clarity and brevity. Be succinct and direct.
>
> What lessons have you learned that you might want to relay? (Please
> enumerate.)
Date: Mon, 12 Feb 2007 18:27:01 GMT
Message-ID: <Vj2Ah.5578$R71.84637_at_ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca>
Bob Badour wrote:
> JOG wrote:
>
>> I am finding the whole experience of trying to relay to others what I >> have learnt on cdt incredibly frustrating and disillusioning.
>
> Let's not let that happen. Teaching the wrong lesson will frustrate.
> Addressing the wrong audience will frustrate. Using an ineffective
> approach will frustrate. Can you think of any other potential causes of
> frustration?
>
> I have a conjecture--perhaps even an hypothesis: With intellectual
> honesty and sincerity, one can choose effectiveness.
>
> Let's start by taking an inventory. When answering the following, strive
> for clarity and brevity. Be succinct and direct.
>
> What lessons have you learned that you might want to relay? (Please
> enumerate.)
- The self-proclaimed seldom are.
- Not every human mind is equally able.
- Intellectual honesty is a prerequisite to learning.
- Not every human mind is capable of abstraction.
- Some non-human minds are capable of experimentation and methodology.
- Success is context-sensitive.
- Our tools affect our minds.
- The predicate calculus is more illuminating than the set algebra.
- Programmers are drawn more to the algebra than the calculus.
- Theoretically non-updatable views should nevertheless be updatable.
- It is very difficult to respond coherently to that which is incoherent.
- Good intentions can lead to disaster.
- Selfish motives can lead to great good.
- Continuous assessment and improvement are best.
- Empiricism is the only hope to understand reality.
- Caution is appropriate when designing.
- Wanton recklessness is appropriate when imagining.
- The scientific method keeps natural human deficiencies in check.
- We should strive to tackle problems at or near the limit of our capability.
- Austere mental discipline is required for real progress.
- A pleasant demeanor can make nastiness palatable.
- An unpleasant demeanor can unmask intellectual dishonesty.
- Some with an unpleasant demeanor are simply nasty.
- There is no stopping the invincibly ignorant.
- Humans tend toward irrational and non-rational belief.
- Status hierarchies are very important to human happiness.
> What audiences do you try to reach with these lessons?
1. Family 2. Friends 3. The readers of c.d.t
> What approaches have you used?
- Profanity
- Intimidation
- Disdain
- Understatement
- Overstatement
- Provocation
- Asking questions
- Absense
- Sophistry
- Referral to better sources
- Self study
- Appeal to reason
- Logic
> What other approaches are you aware of?
- Absolute empiricism with quiet skepticism
> What other audiences might exist?
- Colleagues
- Students
- Web surfers
- Other programmers and data managers
- Other types of professionals
- Executives
- Academics
- Random strangers
> What big questions remain unanswered in your mind?
- What are the biggest challenges to distributed optimization?
- Where will the next great insights lead us?
- How will germline genetic engineering affect our offspring?
- How long will it take to achieve engineered negligible senescence?
- Where can I best devote my effort?
- When I gain an insight
- When I communicate an insight
- When someone exceeds my expectations
- When I see something admirable
- When I improve an efficiency
- When I remove a systemic defect
- When it compiles
- When it behaves as expected in the debugger
- When it runs
- When my dogs run and play
- When I increase my serenity