Re: Fraud Number 1: MARSHALL

From: Cimode <>
Date: 17 Jun 2006 13:16:47 -0700
Message-ID: <>

Some more fo MARSHALL enlighteninng ideas about Mathematics//

This one is a nice dream of his redefining his own mathematics concepts

//Is 3 a real thing? I used to wonder about that. And in fact I  have put the question directly to a few of the best minds in  computer science. They mostly shrug. I now see why: it's  not that interesting a question.// --> Think they shrug because you looked so silly,they did not want to make you look ridiculous...

//Me//--> puzzled I answer
 I do not quite understand what you are getting at...3 is the  mathematical symbol representing a number value extracted from an  ensemble of both reals and integer subset.

//MARSHALL// -->^persists and signs claiming basically that 3 <> 3

In strict English grammar, we would say "3" is the mathematical symbol representing a number value. But 3 is not the same thing as "3". 3 is the actual number; the successor to 2, *not* the glyph. "3" is a real thing, because symbols *do* appear in the natural world. You see them on pages of math books all the time. But is 3 a real thing, the way horses are real and unicorns are not real?

I rather think 3 has more in common with unicorns than with horses. (This is of course a metaphoric statement rather than a literal one.) But I find 3 to be ... useful nonetheless.

--> He uses UNICORNS AND HORSES to explain his defficient dream of

I let people judge for themselves HOw can somebody who state such idiotic statement be thrusted as somebody who understand RM which is mathematics applied.. Received on Sat Jun 17 2006 - 22:16:47 CEST

Original text of this message